Skip to content

Leave Us a Review

Our customers are the center of our universe and we’re grateful for them. If you’re willing to share your experience about your interaction with our agency, it’ll be a great help for other people looking to make smart and confident decisions about their insurance and financial services.


Take 60 seconds (or more if you want) to share your story by clicking on one of the review links below.

What our customers say about us...

Profile photo of Stephanie Astor

Stephanie Astor

May 30, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Stephanie Astor
"I worked with Ally Herstein at John Simone agency. She is a wealth of knowledge, so responsive, and provided a thorough quote and service. State Farm has always taken exceptional care of me and I cannot recommend them enough, and Ally in particular! Her attention to detail and service are top notch."
Profile photo of Karina Valdez

Karina Valdez

May 26, 2026

4  out of  5
rating by Karina Valdez
"Update: I originally gave this office 5 stars, and I actually meant to update my review a while ago, but life has been busy. Recently, communication and follow-up have not been the best, which was disappointing after being a loyal client for about six years. I felt unheard during a few interactions, and it honestly made me reconsider staying with this office. However, I do want to recognize John. He personally followed up with me, listened to my concerns, and genuinely made me feel valued as a client again. His professionalism and customer service truly stood out. If anyone ever has a negative experience with someone at this office, I highly recommend reaching out to John directly. He is amazing and truly cares about his clients. Review from 2020 After reading the great reviews I decided to give it a try... John is a wonderful agent, I knew it since the first time I spoke to him over the phone and confirmed that when I met with him at his office to discuss about changes in my policy. He spent a lot of time answering my questions, going over my policy information, and explaining me my options. I wish every sales person was like him, he will rather be honest with costumers and he won't try make money lying to them or hiding charges and things like that. He really cares about costumers and knows how to do business. I would highly recommend him to anyone."
We responded:
"Karina, thank you for your honest, heartfelt review. I truly appreciate it, look forward to serving you and am glad I was able to help you save money!"
Profile photo of Suzanne Pasha

Suzanne Pasha

May 21, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Suzanne Pasha
"Fast and easy to set up renter's insurance. Tyler was helpful with determining what we needed."
We responded:
"Suzanne, Thank you for sharing your 5 star experience with us! Fast, simple & easy is what we aim for every time. We appreciate your trust in helping with your son's renters insurance. "
Profile photo of Ashton Pedersen

Ashton Pedersen

May 18, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Ashton Pedersen
"Got my first renters insurance policy, and John made it as easy as can be. Definitely will be getting my future policies with his team. Highly recommend!"
We responded:
"Ashton, thank you for choosing us to help with your need for personal insurance for your first policy. We love working with younger customers like you! The goal is to keep this easy and simple because it doesn't have to be difficult. Welcome to our agency! "
Profile photo of Metal Grandpa

Metal Grandpa

April 28, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Metal Grandpa
"Thanks for setting me up with my auto, renters, and life insurance."
We responded:
"Adam, We appreciate the opportunity to serve and earn your business. I'm very glad we helped you get to the bottom of what was most important for you in your protection plan. Thank you for your trust and confidence! We also love your guide name! "
Profile photo of Perrine Haeg

Perrine Haeg

April 20, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Perrine Haeg
"Great team to work with! John and Ally are very professionals"
We responded:
"Perrine, Ally & I appreciate the opportunity to work with you and Danny. Thank you for taking the time to share your experience with 5 stars! We're excited to serve and earn your business with 5 star service! Welcome to our agency. "
Profile photo of marissa winegarden

marissa winegarden

April 20, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by marissa winegarden
"Ally Herstein in John's office is amazing. She is customer first, friendly and very knowledgeable. Insurance can be overwhelming and she makes it easy and stress free. Call her for insurance needs!"
We responded:
"Marissa, thank you for sharing your experience with Ally. No worries, be happy! :) We greatly appreciate your confidence, trust and are really glad to hear that we're your "That Was Easy" insurance button! We look forward to working with, serving you and appreciate the opportunity to earn your business. "
Profile photo of Dana Sullivan

Dana Sullivan

April 3, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Dana Sullivan
"Excellent service! Highly recommend"
We responded:
"Dana! Thank you for recommendation! We appreciate and respect your relationship as a long term customer. We look forward to continuing our ability to provide you the value and service you prefer. Thank you for being a great customer!"
Profile photo of Luis Morato

Luis Morato

March 31, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Luis Morato
"I am new to the US and needed insurance ASAP. John Simeone and Ally Herstein guided me through the whole process within hours. Thank you!"
We responded:
"Luis, we're glad we could help you efficiently and quickly! Thank you for the opportunity to serve you and welcome to our agency!"
Profile photo of Jasmine Albrecht

Jasmine Albrecht

March 24, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Jasmine Albrecht
"Tyler was very helpful throughout the entire insurance selection process. Purchasing a home might be stressful but getting the insurance taken taken care of in such a straightforward and timely manner provided great peace of mind. Tyler is friendly and went through everything in detail. I highly recommend!"
We responded:
"Jasmine, we appreciate and thank you for sharing your experience with Tyler! Tyler is a valued agent on our team who helps new customers just like you create a plan that best fits your family's need and protection. Thank you for your trust and being one of our newest valued customers! "
Profile photo of Cooper Rosenlund

Cooper Rosenlund

February 24, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Cooper Rosenlund
"John is seriously the best insurance agent I’ve ever had! Just recently I bought a new vehicle, I emailed him on a Saturday morning and within a couple of hours I had proof of insurance on it. Not to mention his timely responses, ability to get all the information he needs at one go, and maybe most importantly he is always trying to save me money 😁. I could not recommend him enough, and will continue to use him for all my insurance needs."
We responded:
"Thank you for sharing your review Cooper! One of the best aspects of my job is that I get to give to clients like you, the values I personally appreciate and enjoy as a consumer. Timeliness, efficiency and personalized attention......... and who doesn't love to save money?! I appreciate the opportunity to serve you & Cambrie. "
Profile photo of Joshua Boyle

Joshua Boyle

February 18, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Joshua Boyle
"Before talking to John, I knew nothing about insurance besides the fact that I just needed to have needed it. He helped me through the whole process explaining what my policy options were and what they entailed and how each one would benefit me. He showed me how bundling is cheaper, I now get a lower car insurance rate. I went from paying $337 A month on just car insurance to $155 On vehicle insurance, life insurance and renter insurance. John was very personable, patient, knowledgeable, and he answered all my questions in a way where I could have a better understanding which took away all the previous anxiety I had about the whole process of switching off my family’s insurance and moving out and getting my own. I recommend John to anybody looking to get insured especially those who know nothing about insurance yet. He will walk you through the whole process and at the end of the conversation you will be set free of the stress of the unknown knowing that he looks in your best interest. Like a good neighbor. John Simeone is there!!!"
We responded:
"Josh, I'm grateful you allowed me the opportunity to help you branch off your parent's plan. I'm humbled by your glowing review. I look forward to serving you for years to come. Thank you for your confidence and trust!"
Profile photo of cdbabs1

cdbabs1

February 12, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by cdbabs1
"i worked with Ally, very prompt with returning calls and emails outstanding price on full coverage almost 100 dollars less each month!!!!!!!"
We responded:
"Thank you for taking the time to share your 5-star experience with us! We look forward to working with and serving you. Everything is off to a great start!"
Profile photo of Noah Farber

Noah Farber

February 5, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Noah Farber
"I've really enjoyed working with John on the insurance for my new condo! He is super knowledgeable and brought me along for every step in the process. I highly recommend his services"
We responded:
"Noah, thank you for being a great new customer and placing your confidence in us! You had options and choices.......... and chose my team and I. We don't take that for granted. I look forward to serving you and thank you for your recommendation in your review! "
Profile photo of Anna Tsakakis

Anna Tsakakis

January 28, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Anna Tsakakis
"John is so helpful, detailed and clear! I had no idea how to begin getting car insurance and he helped me through every step and made it easy."
We responded:
"Anna, congratulations again on your new car and thank you for your review! I'm glad I could make getting your new car insurance easy. Thank you for the opportunity to help out."
Profile photo of Leigh Anne Lopez

Leigh Anne Lopez

January 23, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Leigh Anne Lopez
"If I could give John 100 stars, I would. Not only was he accommodating to our hectic schedule, he was so personable, honest, up front and just a great vibe. He really laid it out for us to understand and even then, when he provided our quotes, we were shocked at how much we were going to save compared to our previous insurance. Also, having a direct agent rather than dealing with the hoops of customer service is such a relief. I will always recommend him to anyone who asks if I know someone!"
We responded:
"Leigh Anne & Cesar, what a great review which reminds me why I love what I do! I'm most grateful to have connected with great people like you both. It's a joy to know you've helped people accomplish getting to a better place with their protection plan. And congratulations on your new home! I look forward to serving your family. "
Profile photo of Jesse Simons

Jesse Simons

January 15, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Jesse Simons
"It is incredibly hard to find an agent like John Simeone. He brings a rare level of professionalism and advocacy to the insurance industry, consistently going above and beyond for his clients. John stands out because of his deep understanding of individual insurance needs. He doesn’t just provide a policy; he ensures you are fully protected with a plan tailored specifically to your life. Having John in your corner means having a true advocate who handles every detail with integrity and care. I cannot recommend him highly enough for anyone seeking a top tier agent."
We responded:
"Jesse, wow! I'm a bit speechless and grateful. Thank you for taking the time to craft your experience into such a humbling review and testimonial. I'm most appreciative and thankful! "
Profile photo of Darrell Pratt

Darrell Pratt

January 2, 2026

4  out of  5
rating by Darrell Pratt
"Jacob has been very helpful with my auto insurance he explain everything step by step. I would refer my friend and family to him thank you 😊"
We responded:
"Thank you for taking the time to share your review Darrell! We appreciate your trust and the opportunity to help you. Welcome to our agency! "
Profile photo of Jasmine Mlejnek

Jasmine Mlejnek

November 14, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Jasmine Mlejnek
"Great experience overall! John was efficient and took time explaining the policy in detail with me. Highly recommend."
We responded:
"Jasmine, I'm really glad we got connected to get you better options and rates. Now you also have a solid understanding of what your coverage does and pay for. Thank you for allowing me to help and welcome to my agency!"
Profile photo of Dan Wheelock

Dan Wheelock

November 7, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Dan Wheelock
"Been with John for years and he and Ally are awesome! Very kind and helpful!"
We responded:
"Thank you Dan! It's always a pleasure working with you on your auto, renters, small business insurance and questions you may have! Accidents sometimes happen and that's what your insurance is there for. Thank you for calling me first so I could help you navigate the claims process and hopefully put your concerns to rest."
Profile photo of Hailey Kepler

Hailey Kepler

October 21, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Hailey Kepler
"I had a great experience working with Issac. He was friendly, professional and explained everything clearly. He helped me find the right coverage for my needs and made the process easy. Highly Recommend!"
We responded:
"Thank you for your great review Hailey! Isaac & I appreciate being able to help out, get you the right coverage and save you $$$! We're grateful to for the opportunity to serve you. "
Profile photo of Linda Gordon

Linda Gordon

October 9, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Linda Gordon
"Tyler was very prompt in returning my call. He had all the information needed for us to make the decision to switch insurance companies. Thankyou Tyler"
We responded:
"Linda, Thank you for sharing your experience with Tyler We greatly appreciate it! We look forward to serving you and are grateful for the opportunity to help. Welcome to our agency! "
Profile photo of Caleb Orth

Caleb Orth

October 9, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Caleb Orth
"Isaac was so easy to work with, and made everything really easy to understand"
We responded:
"Caleb, welcome to our agency! Isaac and I are grateful we made getting a new insurance plan easy to understand. Keeping it simple is what we aim for with everyone we serve. Thank you for the opportunity to earn your business. "
Profile photo of Ben Leaf

Ben Leaf

September 20, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Ben Leaf
"Very personable and helpful staff. They did a fantastic job helping me navigate the switch over to State Farm, and saved me some money too. A+"
We responded:
"Thank you for sharing your A+ experience with us Ben! Its our pleasure to have the opportunity to help you get better coverage and save $$$ too. We appreciate your trust and confidence! "
Profile photo of Matthew Czerniak

Matthew Czerniak

August 20, 2025

5  out of  5
rating by Matthew Czerniak
"Love working with this team! Fair rates, very responsive, and always eager to help out. Ally is my go to rep here. Ask for her - She's great!"
We responded:
"Matthew, thank you sharing your experience with our team! Ally and all of us in the office appreciate your trust and confidence to help you the way you want to be served! "